United NationsDepartment of Economic and Social Affairs Sustainable Development

Voluntary Local Reviews

Related

11

Background

When adopting the 2030 Agenda, United Nations member States committed to working closely with local and regional governments on the implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Since 2015, metropolises, small cities, regions and their associations alike have been actively localizing the 2030 Agenda, bringing the SDGs closer to the people they serve and using the framework as a tool for planning and execution.

As part of its follow-up and review mechanisms, the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development encourages member States to "conduct regular and inclusive reviews of progress at the national and sub-national levels, which are country-led and country-driven" (paragraph 79). Paragraph 89 of the 2030 Agenda calls on major groups and other stakeholders, including local authorities, to report on their contribution to the implementation of the Agenda.

In this spirit, local and regional governments are increasingly engaging in such sub-national reviews of SDG implementation, also called Voluntary Local Reviews (VLRs). While the VLRs hold no official status, the process of undertaking these sub-national reviews is providing multiple benefits to the entities engaging in them and to SDG implementation at large. These VLRs can also help to reinforce vertical coherence and complement and contribute to the national Voluntary National Reviews of SDG implementation.

The documents and reports submitted by cities and regions that are available on this website have been placed on the platform as received. The designations employed do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the Secretariat of the United Nations concerning the legal status of any country, territory or area, or of its authorities, or concerning its frontiers or boundaries.

 

Voluntary Local Reviews

You can see below the reports submitted to the Department of Economic and Social Affairs of the United Nations.

If you would like to submit a Voluntary Local Review report developed by your city/region/province, please, send a pdf version to dsdg@un.org with the Subject: Voluntary Local Review from [Add the name of the city/region/province and country]. Reports can be submitted by representatives of subnational governments. If your report is not written in one of the 6 official UN languages (English, Arabic, Russian, Chinese, French, Spanish), we request that you submit an executive summary with the main messages in English in addition to your VLR report. Submissions are reviewed on a regular basis.

Search in the reports
Year Local / regional government Country Report(s) Language Member State VNR
2021 City of Subang Jaya Malaysia Subang Jaya Voluntary Local Review 2021, Implementing the 2030 Agenda in the City of Subang Jaya English 2020 VNR
2021 Pará State Government Brazil 2nd VLR_State of Pará_Brazil English 2017 VNR
2021 Asker municipality Norway Agenda 2030 in Asker, Voluntary local review 2021 English 2021 VNR
2021 City of Helsinki Finland From Agenda to Action: Implementation of the UN Sustainable Development Goals in Helsinki 2021 English 2020 VNR
2021 City of Ghent Belgium Ghent Sustainability Report 2021 - Focus on People - Voluntary Local Review English VNR 2017
2021 Municipalidad de Lima Peru INFORME LOCAL VOLUNTARIO-LIMA-2021 Spanish 2020 VNR Report (Spanish)
2021 Government of the State of Durango Mexico Informe Subnacional Voluntario (ISV) - Durango 2021 Spanish 2021 VNR
2021 City of Los Angeles United States 2021 Voluntary Local Review of Progress Toward The Sustainable Development Goals in Los Angeles English
2021 Government of Mexico City Mexico Mexico City, a City of Innovation and Rights - Voluntary Local Review Spanish 2021 VNR
2021 City of Orlando United States Orlando and the Sustainable Development Goals - A Voluntary Local Review of Progress English
2021 Government of the State of Mexico Mexico Revisión voluntaria: Estado de México. Avance en el cumplimiento de la Agenda 2030 Spanish 2021 VNR
2021 City of Vantaa Finland Sustainable Vantaa belongs to Everyone English 2020 VNR
2021 Municipality of Gladsaxe Denmark The 2030 Agenda on the Local Level: A Voluntary Review from Gladsaxe, Denmark English 2021 VNR Report, 2017 VNR
2021 City of Shah Alam Malaysia The implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development in the City of Shah Alam English 2017 VNR
2021 Tokyo Metropolitan Government Japan Tokyo Sustainability Action English 2017 VNR
2021 City of Yokohama Japan VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 2021 YOKOHAMA - Report on the Implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development English 2021 VNR
2021 City of Malmo Sweden Voluntary Local Review City of Malmo 2021 English 2021 VNR
2021 City of Stockholm Sweden Voluntary Local Review City of Stockholm 2021 , Voluntary Local Review City of Stockholm 2021 English 2021 VNR
2021 City of Helsingborg Sweden Voluntary local review of Helsingborg English 2021 VNR
2021 Government of Yiwu China Voluntary Local Review_Yiwu English 2021 VNR (Chinese), 2021 VNR (English)
2020 Basque Country Government Spain 4th Monitoring Report I Agenda Euskadi Basque Country 2030 Basque 2021 VNR
2020 City of Bonn Germany Agenda 2030 on the local level: implementation of the un sustainable development goals in bonn English 2021 VNR
2020 City of Barcelona Spain Barcelona: Sustainable Future , Barcelona: Futuro Sostenible , Barcelona: Futur Sostenible English, Catalan, Spanish 2021 VNR, 2018 VNR
2020 City of Espoo Finland Espoo Voluntary Local Review English 2020 VNR
2020 City of Ghent Belgium Ghent Sustainability Report 2020 - Voluntary Local Review English 2017 VNR
2020 City of Stuttgart Germany Lebenswertes Stuttgart Die globale Agenda 2030 auf lokaler Ebene English 2021 VNR
2020 Montevideo City Government Uruguay Montevideo Sustainable Development Goals - First Voluntary Review 2020 English 2019 VNR
2020 Government of Wallonia Belgium Où en est la Wallonie par rapport aux Objectifs de Développement Durable? French 2016 VNR
2020 City of Pittsburgh United States Pittsburgh and the Sustainable Development Goals - A Voluntary Local Review of Progress English
2020 São Paulo City Hall Brazil Report of Localization of Sustainable Development Goals in São Paulo , Informe De Localización De Los Objetivos De Desarrollo Sostenible En La Ciudad De São Paulo , Relatório De Localização Dos Objetivos De Desenvolvimento Sustentável Na Cidade De São Paulo English, Spanish, Portuguese 2017 VNR, 2017 VNR
2020 City of Skiathos Greece Skiathos VLR 2020 English
2020 City of Turku Finland The Implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development in the City of Turku English 2020 VNR
2020 City of Guangzhou China Vibrancy, Inclusion, and Openness; a Mega-City's Road Towards Green Development - UN SDGs Guangzhou Voluntary Local Review English 2021 VNR Report [English], 2021 VNR
2020 City of Buenos Aires Argentina Voluntary Local Review - Buenos Aires Adaptation of the 2030 Agenda (2020) English 2020 VNR
2020 Government of the State of Pará Brazil Voluntary Local Review on the Sustainable Development Goals in the State of Pará - Brazil English Full Report HLPF 2017 - Brazil (English), 2017 VNR
2020 Government of the State of Yucatan Mexico Voluntary Subnational Report Yucatan 2020 , Informe Subnacional Voluntario Yucatán 2020 English, Spanish 2018 VNR, 2018 VNR (Spanish)
2019 São Paulo State Government Brazil 1st Progress Report on the Sustainable Development Goals in São Paulo State , 1st Progress Report on the Sustainable Development Goals in São Paulo State Portuguese, English 2017 VNR, 2017 VNR
2019 Basque Country Government Spain 3rd Monitoring Report I Agenda Euskadi Basque Country 2030 English 2021 VNR (Spanish)
2019 City of Los Angeles United States Toolbar items Manage Administration menu Tools Content Shortcuts dannia.philipp@un.org A Voluntary Local Review of Pr English
2019 Bristol City Council United Kingdom Bristol and the SDGs: A Voluntary Local Review of Progress 2019 English 2019 VNR
2019 City of Helsinki Finland From Agenda to Action - The Implementation of the UN Sustainable Development Goals in Helsinki 2019 English 2020 VNR
2019 City of Mexico Mexico Innovation and Rights; A Program To Advance Sustainable Development in Mexico City English 2018 VNR, 2018 VNR (Spanish)
2019 City of New York United States New York City’s Implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development English
2019 Government of the State of Santana de Parnaíba Brazil Santana de Parnaíba 2030 Vision Connected to the Future Portuguese 2017 VNR, 2017 VNR
2019 City of Mannheim Germany The implementation of the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals in Mannheim English 2021 VNR
2019 City of Buenos Aires Argentina Voluntary Local Review Building a sustainable and inclusive Buenos Aires English 2020 VNR (Spanish)
2019 Government of the State Oaxaca Mexico Voluntary Subnational Review English 2018 VNR Report, 2018 VNR
2018 Basque Country Government Spain 2030 Agenda of Basque Country Basque, Spanish, English 2021 VNR
2018 Basque Country Government Spain 2nd Monitoring Report I Agenda Euskadi Basque Country 2030 English 2021 VNR
2018 City of Kitakyushu Japan Kitakyushu City the Sustainable Development Goals Report English 2021 VNR

Resources

Global Guiding Elements for Voluntary Local Reviews

The Global Guiding Elements for Voluntary Local Reviews (available for download in EnglishArabic, Chinese, Russian, Spanish and French) provide a starting point for local and regional governments considering producing their own Voluntary Local Review and aim to give an overview of useful focus areas for the review process and the eventual report. As such, they are not meant to be prescriptive nor restrictive.

Given the variety of local and regional governments conducting reviews of their SDG implementation, these Global Guiding Elements do not aim at addressing best practices for institutional arrangements, data collection or stakeholder engagement, but merely highlight areas that could be addressed in the VLR process. Hence, the guiding elements aim at providing a low-threshold entry point to VLRs by showcasing a check list of issues that could be addressed.

The Global Guiding Elements aim at enhancing peer learning, including through promotion of consistency and comparability between reports of subnational governments, whether regions or cities. They also aim at providing a framework that, building on the SDGs as the common language among all levels of government, enhances the dialogue between the Voluntary National Reviews and the Voluntary Local Reviews and relevant actors at all levels. They draw upon the Secretary-General’s Voluntary common reporting guidelines for voluntary national reviews, developed by UN DESA, which have proven useful for member States’ efforts in reporting on their progress.

Guidance materials for conducting a subnational review of SDG implementation

A number of other actors have produced useful guidance and reference materials aimed at supporting cities and regions in conducting their reviews of SDG implementation: 

Shimokawa Method for Voluntary Local Reviews

Institute for Global Environmental Strategies has published in April 2020 the Shimokawa Method for Voluntary Local Reviews. The handbook provides a hands-on, step-by-step method to conduct VLRs and comprises of ten steps. Each step highlights a critical aspect needed to successfully conduct a VLR. It also contains the VLR Format for reference.

United Cities and Local Governments: SDGs Learning Module 3: Reporting to national & local reviews

As part of its online training series, United Cities and Local Governments (UCLG) published in June 2019 the SDGs Learning Module 3: Reporting to national & local reviews. The objective of Module 3 is to enhance the involvement of local and regional government associations (LRGAs) in the preparation of national VNRs and to help them to make their own reports on the involvement of LRGs in the pursuit of localizing of the SDGs and global agendas, as well as to support local governments in the reporting exercise.

Cities Taking the Lead on the Sustainable Development Goals - a Voluntary Local Review Handbook for Cities

Brookings Institution has made available a Voluntary Local Review Handbook for Cities The goal of the Handbook is to provide guidance, templates, and case studies to cities and local authorities interested in producing a Voluntary Local Review (VLR) or an initial report to stakeholders on how city programs and services work towards the SDGs. The information aims at helping cities decide where to start and which components to include in such a report. The Handbook was developed by a team of students from Carnegie Mellon University’s Heinz College of Information Systems and Public Policy.

The European Handbook for SDG Voluntary Local Review

The European Commission’s Joint Research Centre has published a Handbook to help cities measure their progress towards the SDGs. The Handbook provides examples of official and experimental indicators useful to set up an effective SDG local monitoring system. Per each Goal, the Handbook highlights examples of harmonised and locally collected indicators so that cities can both benchmark themselves with other cities and monitor their own specific needs and challenges.

Cabot Institute for the Environment's VLR Handbook

The VLR Handbook was produced in collaboration with the Bristol One City Office. Bristol was the first UK city to have carried out a Voluntary Local Review and the handbook provides information about the approach adopted in Bristol. Bristol’s VLR was one of the few that has involved citywide engagement of the activities that organizations within the city have undertaken towards the SDGs through. This handbook shares the methods used to undertake this consultation and provides specific discussions around some of the biggest challenges faced in Bristol while developing the VLR. The handbook contains data sources that will be of specific use of UK cities but the learning from Bristol’s citywide approach that assessed progress towards all 17 SDGs will likely be useful to cities everywhere.

Asia-Pacific Regional Guideline on Voluntary Local Reviews (UNESCAP)

The United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (UNESCAP) together with the Penang Platform for Sustainable Urbanization (PPSU) is working on a Regional Guideline which aims at supporting cities in their VLR process. Given the varied institutional environment across the region in terms of enabling local actions, the guideline is also expected to support cities in partnering with relevant national authorities and other stakeholders for bottom-up action processes through a multi-level governance approach to SDGs. It will contain guidance, templates, and case studies specific to the Asia-Pacific region that can help cities decide how and where to start a VLR process and components to include in their VLR report.

UCLG-UN-Habitat Guidelines for Voluntary Local Reviews Vol.1

The first volume of the Guidelines for VLRs is part of a larger partnership between UCLG and UN-Habitat: the VLR Series. The latter is aimed at providing cities and LRGs with cutting-edge knowledge and practical guidance on the VLR process, while kindling the sharing of experience and practices — and, ultimately, a global conversation — on monitoring and reporting on the SDGs at the local level. The Vol.1 of the Guidelines for VLRs offers a comparative analysis of existing VLRs, especially exploring the key elements to start with the VLR process: a) what institutions and actors are being involved in a VLR?; b) where is the VLR process located institutionally in the broader scheme of multilevel governance?; c) what contents are VLRs including, and why?; d) how are VLRs being made, with what resources and what goals?

Events