Sorry, you need to enable JavaScript to visit this website.
United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Sustainable Development

Pilot projects on statistics data collection in indigenous communities of Panama and El Salvador

    Description
    Intro

    Indigenous peoples in Central America have expressed disagreement with the way in which statistics have being collected in their territories, mainly those published by the National Statistical Offices, since they consider that they do not reflect their real needs and cosmovision. For that reason, FAO proposes data collection projects in indigenous territories of Panama and El Salvador, aimed at improving the quality of the statistics on indigenous peoples by editing the questionnaires currently used to data collection. The results will show the items to be modified and the options that allow each question to be exhaustive especially for indigenous peoples.

    Objective of the practice

    The main goal is to improve the statistical measurements in indigenous territories by rethinking the questionnaire used in the Households Survey in Panama and in the Population and Housing Census questionnaire in El Salvador. Those improvements were designed to reflect the cultural conceptions, indigenous languages, traditional rules, and social and productive organization to provide the best inputs for the development of social policies, plans and projects in these territories. The projects were also a practical response to the best implementation of the SDGs, emphasizing in SDG 1 and SDG2, to be scaled in other statistical offices to improve the measurements.<br />
    <br />
    A vital part of this pilot is the link with SDG 2: End hunger, achieve food security, improve nutrition, and promote sustainable agriculture; and with the goal 2.1: Prevalence of food insecurity according to experience scale through the inclusion of the FIES scale. The inclusion of this module in both pilots was a way to verify the performance of this measurement in the indigenous territories and obtain the greatest amount of information. It was also important for the National Household Survey of Panama, to be developed in March 2019, and the considerations for its optimal survey in indigenous communities in order to obtain timely and good quality measurements. <br />
    <br />
    The generation of food security data in indigenous areas allows countries to generate statistics, disaggregated data and the relationships between food insecurity, indigenous groups and social variables that could represent an important advance for the statistical system in Panama and El Salvador.<br />
    One of the great challenges was to generate trust in the authorities and the indigenous population in the collection of information in their territories; how this improvement implied the support of the community; and how a better information have positive impacts on the relations within territories and with the governmental authorities. Technicians faced that challenges by applying the Free, Prior and Informed Consent managed with each of the indigenous authorities in Panama and El Salvador, including a detailed explanation to the community about the advantages of being able to statistically visualize them, languages, environment and ways of life of indigenous peoples.<br />
    <br />
    In Panama, location of some communities was a challenge to take into account, faced with optimal technical preparation between the National Statistics Body of Panama (INEC) and FAO.<br />
    <br />
    In El Salvador, the main challenges were to reach consensus between actors’ involved in the process, recruitment and training staff in the field, and logistic issues. Hiring and training personnel from the same community to apply the census pilot survey solved most of challenges. That solution allowed FAO and DIGESTYC to update the cartography, apply the questionnaire in the same language of the dwellers and build confidence in the community. What it was a limitation at the beginning become an affirmative action that allowed a better approach to people, improving the quality of the answers.

    Partners
    In Panama, 385 households distributed in Emberá-Wounaan and Guna territories and in the Ngäbe Bugle Comarca, were surveyed in the pilot of the Household Survey.

    In El Salvador, the pilot of the population / housing census included 4 068 households, the entire Cacaopera Municipality of the department of Morazán.

    The project was implemented by the National Statistics Bodies (INEC of Panama) and (DIGESTYC of El Salvador) with support from FAO.

    Innovative associations: Indigenous organizations, Ministry of Government (MINGOB) in Panama and Government of El Salvador.
    Implementation of the Project/Activity

    PLANNING:
    • Intersectoral coordination between agencies and institutions involved to coordinate work schedules, selected locations, statistical operation, financial resources, technical personnel and logistical support required for field operations.
    • Panama: Technical Secretary of the Social Cabinet, Ministry of Government (MINGOB), Institute of Statistics (INEC) and FAO.
    • El Salvador: Regional Government of Morazán, DIGESTYC, UNFPA, and FAO.
    • Presentation of the data collection pilot in indigenous territories to the communities and traditional authorities in Panama and El Salvador. The Free Prior and Informed Consent as a work tool.
    • Selection of human resources in Panama and El Salvador with the support of indigenous authorities (people from these communities).
    • Recruitment of interviewers, supervisors and cartographers.

    VALIDATION OF THE HOUSEHOLD SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE (Panama) AND QUESTIONNAIRE OF THE CENSUS POPULATION (Cacaopera, El Salvador)

    • Meetings with the community and authorities to validate the questionnaires.
    • Approach to Free Prior and Informed Consent as a tool for work and coordination with the communities involved in these initiatives.
    • Design and rethink the questionnaire questions already mentioned, delivery to INEC-Panama and DIGESTYC El Salvador.
    CAPACITY BUILDING
    • Training for interviewers and supervisors.
    • Training for cartographers. (Only in Cacaopera, El Salvador)

    ANALYSIS OF iNFORMATION

    • In progress

    DIFFUSION

    • The statistical outputs of the variables of interest will be shared with the community and indigenous authorities in Panama in a workshop to present and discuss the information and its usefulness as inputs for the development and visibility of these territories.

    • DIGESTYC and FAO have already been establishing meetings with indigenous organizations (Salvadorian Indigenous Coordinating Council) for the dissemination and discussion of basic statistics of the Cacaopera municipality generated through the indigenous pilot. Likewise, DIGESTYC with the support of FAO, will generate a technical report with relevant statistics on food security for the Cacaopera region.

    Results/Outputs/Impacts
    The results of both initiatives will generate relevant statistical information, agreed with the informants and politically feasible for the development and visibility of these population groups, always under the SDG’s vision “Do not leave anyone behind". This opens up the possibility of looking at the questionnaires as dynamic and flexible tools, able to gather information according to people’s needs and taking into account their culture and lifestyle.
    Thus, these projects were a great opportunity to contribute the progress on the SDG measure, in particular SDG 2 (indicator 2.1.2) in Panama and El Salvador.

    In addition, this initiative also complies with the commitments acquired in the National Plan of Action of Indigenous Peoples of El Salvador (PLANPIES), putting into practice The Prior, Free And Informed Consent whose purpose was to carry out consultations to inform the activities to be developed in their territories and get their consent.

    In 2019, Panama decided to include indigenous as interviewers to the National Household Survey of March 2019, which was possible thanks to the successful experience of this indigenous pilot and the evidence of how these people can substantially increase the quality of the collected data.
    The value of full and effective participation was also promoted throughout the process, with the participation of indigenous peoples in the development and implementation of both pilots and evidencing this strategy as one of the mechanisms to improve the quality of the data collected in indigenous territories.

    In statistical terms, the possibility of identifying relevant cultural aspects within indigenous peoples as traditional dwellings, monetary valuation of these dwellings, indigenous languages present in the community, indigenous self-identification, type of families, indigenous formation, etc. enriches and improves the vision we have of these peoples and gives relevant information to contribute to their development.
    Enabling factors and constraints
    Innovation1: The survey in the field through the questionnaires used in both countries for the population-housing census and household surveys evidenced situations to reconsider some items and sections to reflect the specificities of rural territories indigenous. Interesting situations were evidenced in these sections:

    • "Features of the dwelling": Number and features of traditional indigenous dwellings, coexistence of traditional indigenous and social interest, priority in the possession, etc.
    • "Household occupants":marital status, self-identification by sex and gender, families, etc.
    • "Educational characteristics": written and oral skills in indigenous languages, traditional indigenous training, etc.

    Innovation2: The validation with the communities of the questionnaires showed that the generation of statistics, especially their dissemination in indigenous communities have been unattended. These communities need to know the basic data of their communities as the first step for any initiative to interact with government agencies, NGOs, international organizations or other indigenous peoples. The information must be accessible, clear and capable of generating duly supported initiatives.

    Innovation3: Institutional coordination among government agencies, national statistics offices and international organizations as a mechanism to address the improvement of statistics and generate discussion spaces that allow progress in the quality of measurements in these countries.
    Sustainability and replicability
    Increasing the quality of the measurements through the questionnaires and statistical operations implies a long-term work that involves the agreement with national offices of statistics and government in the need to generate relevant and innovative data for the needs of the country.

    The cost / benefit ratio of this initiative is favorable, which makes it possible to suggest these improvements to other countries, especially for the visualization of particular features that may signify the identification of points of interest for specific groups (indigenous, Afro-descendants, disabled people, etc) for decision-making and public policies.
    Conclusions

    FAO proposal is the generation of relevant and innovative data to understand better rural areas. Indigenous peoples, small farmers and other vulnerable groups have some special differences that are not currently taking in count by national statistical offices. <br />
    <br />
    Having in mind the differences and the need to make them visible is the motivation to improve statistics. Statistical questionnaires must be dynamic, mechanisms that must respond to the generation of information from all social groups, not only from urban areas.<br />
    <br />
    Statistics can be a mechanism for the empowerment, development and resolution of conflicts for indigenous peoples, but should be disseminated in these areas and taking into account their particularities.

    N/A
    N/A
    No progress reports have been submitted. Please sign in and click here to submit one.
    False
    Name Description
    Action Network
    SDG Good Practices First Call
    This initiative does not yet fulfil the SMART criteria.
    Share
    FacebookTwitterLinkedIn
    Timeline
    02 April 2018 (start date)
    28 February 2019 (date of completion)
    Entity
    FAO
    SDGs
    Region
    1. Latin America and the Caribbean
    Geographical coverage
    In Panama, Emberá-Wounaan and Guna territories and Ngäbe Bugle Comarca. In El Salvador, Cacaopera Municipality of the department of Morazán.
    Website/More information
    N/A
    Countries
    Panama
    Panama
    Contact Information

    Verónica Boero, Statistics Officer of FAO for Latin America and the Caribbean