Sorry, you need to enable JavaScript to visit this website.
United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Sustainable Development

“Balde Cheio” Programme (Full Bucket) a farmer-oriented programme of intensifying dairy farming systems in Brazil (SDG 1,2 and 8)

    Description
    Intro

    The Balde Cheio programme aims to develop and adapt production processes and administrative tools for small dairy farmers and extension service technicians. It was launched in 1999 in São Paulo state and gradually spread, reaching more than three thousand family dairy farmers in all regions of the country. With the Balde Cheio programme Embrapa aimed to link research more closely to the needs and situation of users. Technical details of this programme have been analysed in-depth presenting high impact on income generation for family farmers in Brazil.

    Objective of the practice

    The Balde Cheio Project proposes a new look at Technology Transfer process focused on intensive, sustainable and efficient dairy farming. The concept is to carry out the continuous training of technicians using a small family-owned dairy farm as a "practical classroom", where the proposals are debated and adapted to the particular situation of that property and, finally, implemented. The Balde Cheio Program is a technology transfer methodology that contributes to the development of dairy farming in family farms. The main objectives are instruct rural extension professionals and farmers, promote the exchange of information regionally and evaluate the environmental, economic and social impacts of the production systems that adopt the proposed technologies. Training and exchange of information takes place in rural areas, which becomes a classroom, called demonstrative unit (DU). In addition, the program includes theoretical classes, both for extension workers and farmers during regional meetings. Among the technologies and concepts proposed are: pasture irrigation, intensive management of pastures (fertilization and division in paddocks), recovery of soil fertility through organic fertilization and maintenance of the vegetation cover, sowing temperate forages on tropical grasses, concepts of herd structure, concepts of reproduction efficiency, period and persistence of lactation, animal health, environmental preservation and economic management of the activity. Structuring of the farm based on the project guidelines, the DU becomes a reference in the region. The participation of distinct partnerships between different links of milk-related production chains or the agroindustrial dairy complex gives the project a sustainable and dynamic basis, collaborating to a network in which there is an intense exchange of information and knowledge

    Partners
    The Balde Cheio Project was based on training the local technicians hired by local partners, such as government agencies, city halls, cooperatives or associations of farmers with basically a strong practical approach. In 2018 there were 145 partnerships with public institutions (technical assistance and rural extension agencies, municipalities, R&D institutions, financial institutions and the Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Supply) as well as with private institutions (cooperatives, dairy industries, associations, universities and independent professionals). It is observed that the stronger and more structured the local partnerships, the greater the commitment of the parties involved
    Implementation of the Project/Activity

    The development of such technology transfer model for dairy cattle has two important elements. First, given the complexity of the dairy activity, with its multiple interactions between soil, plant, climate, animals, labor and management, the choice of the most appropriate technological options requires specific skills from researchers and local technicians, since there are no identical farms and therefore strategies must be customized. A second element is the significant role of the local technician, who goes beyond the recommendation of technical issues but in decision making and manipulation of production factors of each particular farm. Considering these context, the Balde Cheio Project was based on the training of local technicians who were contracted by local partners, such as government agencies, prefectures, cooperatives or associations of producers with an essentially practical focus, in which small farms were considered the best 'practical classroom' for the training the local extensionist. Working closely with farmers for a long-term training, the responsibilities of technicians and researchers are expanded. Due to several requests in different regions the figure of the “instructor” was created in order to support the researchers' work. Farms used as a 'practical classroom' are the Demonstration Units (UD), and the other properties are now called Assisted Properties (PAs). The costs of the instructors and technicians are paid by the local partnerships or farmers. In this sense, the establishment of local strong partnerships is essential.
    The Full Bucket Program has 5 key elements: (1) Monitoring of climatic, zootechnical and economic variables as a decision-making tool: precise data collection allows a realistic view of the farm and based the decision on facts. (2) Adaptation to complexity and innovations based on the recombination of technologies: the project considers the diversity of socio-economic and socio-cultural-cultural situations, with no standard technological package. (3) Testing and experimentation at farm level as a fundamental tool for learning: Conducting tests for introduction, adaptation and recombination of technologies and practices is carried out gradually according to the situation of the farmer and the intensification process. This exercise reduces risk, and practical mistakes can be corrected without compromising the domestic budget of the farmer. (4) Network for exchange information and practices: The development of a network of rural producers and technicians in the regions and the periodic visits of Embrapa researchers and instructors makes possible the intense circulation of knowledge. (5) The rhythm of technology introduction taking into account the pace of each farmer: The availability of capital, or lack of it, is not the main factor that drives technological innovation. It is also important when and how each new technology practice will be introduced. There are essential preconditions that define the best logical sequence for each selected technology. Rather than simply “copy and paste” processes, producers are encouraged to experiment with a continuous learning process. Learning from other producers should be coupled with local trials. The experience with assisted farmers suggests that the sequence of technological introduction is, for the most cases, more important than the technology itself.

    Results/Outputs/Impacts
    Gradual and balanced investments, mainly provided by a better location of the existing capital, significantly increased the performance of assisted farmers. The increase in milk production at farmers in the State of São Paulo illustrates the potential of the Full Bucket approach. On average, milk volume increased by 2.3 times (from 113 to 260 l / day) in a period of declining trend in state production (-8% between 2003 and 2009) (Novo et al, 2012). The increase in milk production by area and by farm had an effect on economic and zootechnical indicators. The tendency of better performance was also observed in another set of data collected from 50 farmers with at least three years of data monitoring in five different regions. In the five study regions, the average gross margin per hectare almost two-folded. This was obtained by the combination of increases in different indicators such as more milk produced (43%), using less area (-7%), with gains of 54% in the productivity of land and greater productivity per cow (24 %). In addition, there was a significant improvement in labor performance (37%). The higher income was a result of gains in productivity rather than higher milk prices paid to producers, which in the period grew only 7% in real terms (from R$ 0.621/liter to R$ 0.64/liter). Another interesting feature - besides the largest generation of income per property - was the generation of more jobs at the rate of 0.2 men / ha. In other words, farmers who intensify dairy farming generate jobs on the farm, either by hiring more labor or preferentially by involving other family members in the productive process. The results of the Full Bucket can also be evaluated by the Embrapa Social Report: The Social impact was positive at 5.39 points (2013) and 3.31 (2014) 4.10 (2015). Environmental impact was positive at 2.25 points (2013) and 2.66 (2014) and 3.06 (2015). Generation of jobs at the rate of 0.2 direct jobs per additional hectare. Considering from 2003 to 2017 the benefit/cost ratio of technology generation is positive at 31.06.
    Enabling factors and constraints
    Due to the long-term educational process (at least 4 years of practical and theoretical work), the formation of strong partnerships that enable the Full Bucket Project at local level has been the main problem to support and growth in the number of beneficiaries. The Full Bucket project applies some pre-analytic choices that are robust enough to promote change in productivity and income for producers in all Brazilian regions and biomes. From the institutional point of view the project can be considered mature to sustain that the formation of robust productive arrangements is the most important factor. It also requires high coordination and commitment of all involved. From 2017 the formation of a cohesive and structured network allowed the cohesive management of data (socioeconomic, environmental and technological indicators), mining new demands for research, focus on sustainability issues and the organization of institutional communication (brand management and relationship with the press) in a unique and articulated program for the whole country.
    Sustainability and replicability
    The wide scope of the project indicates that the methodology is highly replicable, despite diverse agro-ecological situations, in many biomes and the particular cultural aspect of each locality. The same methodology called attention in other countries and have been applied in Colombia and Panamá. Other agricultural chains are adapting the Full Bucket methodology to the specific conditions of organic milk production (an organic milk cluster in São Carlos, SP), milk production of goats and buffalos, beef cattle, Integrated systems and Coffee. Farmers´ reports (interviewed annually by the AMBITEC SOCIAL methodology) indicate relevant impacts, such as: the organization of the production system and the technical and management improvements result in more milk and income. In addition it also improves milk production throughout the year and farmers food security. Better quality of raw milk was evidenced by the reduction in Somatic Cells and Total Bacterial and by the control of residues, which together with the greater amount of food produced at farm level, is translated into a great impact on food safety. Soil fertility was also improved: farmers reported sensible reduction in erosion, increase in organic matter of the soil, increase in fertility and less compacted soil.
    Conclusions

    The Full Bucket project can be consider quite solid from the point of view of appropriation by the different actors of the dairy chain and by a considerable number of producers, mostly small families. However, the main positive effects of the Balde Cheio do not appear so clearly in the statistics: it is a deep rescue of the self-esteem of small-scale dairy farmers, as well as rural extension workers, who have a better income and enhanced living conditions for all the family. Analysing the challenge to provide information to a universe of 1.3 million dairy farmers, distributed in 99% of Brazilian municipalities, it is clear that much more needs to be done. The Full Bucket Project has the potential to contribute positively to at least three ODSs (1, 2 and 8). With respect to ODS 1 we clearly observe that the increase in income - especially in small family milk producers in underprivileged regions of Brazil - is one of the strongest characteristics of all the work. With respect to ODS 2, there is a potential contribution due to the increase in productivity of land, labor and two other productive resources through access to knowledge, productive inputs and the formation of local productive arrangements. The preferential milk production model - implemented according to the reality of each producer - promotes the recovery of fertility, besides opening areas for protection of water sheds and the correct compliance with the environmental law. ODS 8 may particularly benefit by higher productivity: in 2016 assisted farmers achieved 4484 liters/ha/year which is equivalent to developed countries. The milk activity is known to be highly intensive in the use of labor and with high added value of its main product. As a result of increased scale and productivity, the economy and food security are strengthened at the local and regional level. The greater efficiency of the use of natural resources (land and water) and other production factors - such as labour and capital - allows the sustainable milk production.

    N/A
    Resources
    Other, please specify
    The main value of the project is related to social inclusion of small farmers
    No progress reports have been submitted. Please sign in and click here to submit one.
    False
    Name Description
    Action Network
    SDG Good Practices First Call
    This initiative does not yet fulfil the SMART criteria.
    Share
    FacebookTwitterLinkedIn
    Timeline
    01 January 1998 (start date)
    01 March 2019 (date of completion)
    Entity
    EMBRAPA SOUTHEAST LIVESTOCK
    SDGs
    8 2 1
    Region
    1. Latin America and the Caribbean
    Geographical coverage
    11 states (Bahia, Espírito Santo, Maranhão, Minas Gerais, Pernambuco, Rio de Janeiro, Rio Grande do Norte, Rondônia, Santa Catarina and São Paulo), 373 municipalities, 220 technicians, 1.284 farmers
    Website/More information
    N/A
    Countries
    Brazil
    Brazil
    Contact Information

    ANDRÉ LUIZ MONTEIRO NOVO, PHD